This is Julian's blog, featuring news about Tecnologias en Desarrollo, South America and quite possibly the odd mention of Arsenal FC...

Sunday, November 06, 2005

Holy Times

The 2nd November was yet another Bank Holiday, though I was a bit confused. It was called "All Saints Day" (a universal Christian Feast that honors and remembers all Christian saints, known and unknown), though in reality this is on the 1st November, and what was celebrated was "All Souls Day" otherwise known as "The Day of the Dead".

It is a Roman Catholic day of remembrance for friends and loved ones who have passed away. This comes from the ancient Pagan Festival of the Dead, which celebrated the Pagan belief that the souls of the dead would return for a meal with the family.

The day purposely follows All Saint's Day in order to shift the focus from those in heaven to those in "purgatory" (not a word I use very often.) While the culture in the UK and US is to shy away from discussions of death, Latins embrace it. The day is an opportunity to celebrate the death and the life of loved ones and friends they knew in this world and visiting the cemetery is a popular tradition. At the cemetery, the tomb or burial plot is decorated. The cemetery visit is spent in a picnic environment and Pan de Muertos or "Bread of the Dead" is a traditional bread which is baked and eaten during this celebration. The air is filled with music from bands while the scent of a wide variety of foods wafts through the air.

There is also a Jewish cemetary in Cochabamba which I wanted to visit. There is no equivalent of which I am aware to the Day of the Dead so the cemetary was not surprisingly closed, however a nice caretaker let me in. There are about 400 or so graves, the oldest dates back about 100 years and most of the names were of German origin. According to the caretaker, the community numbers about 80 now in the city and he gave me details of the synagogue.

It was also a busy day for some friends of ours, Carine (from France) and Vincent (from Belgium, see link http://www.vincetmanu.com/), who work for a charity called AVE that supports the children who work in the cemetary. There are about 400 children who help supplement their families' income by carrying out tasks like cleaning graves, selling flowers and running errands in the cemetary. While some of them work full-time, the majority are there in their spare time, at evenings and weekends. They can earn anything from 50p up to £1.50 on a very good day. There are two views: that "child labour" is inhuman and one should do everything possible to ensure it is outlawed, or the latter view that AVE takes, that it can fight for rights for the children and improve and promote their working conditions. The charity also organises positive activities for the children, so that they get to have some fun as well as broadening their experiences and interests. They publish a regular magazine (sold for 7p) and have also produced 3 CDs which contain songs, stories and interviews.

My religious theme week continued the following day. Recently I met Julie in a street near my house, she is a 57 year old English lady from Brentwood in Essex who runs a day centre for children in a poor neighbourhood. She is a bundle of energy and before I knew it I was persuaded to come and visit the centre as well as attend her thursday "Bible Group".

The centre is very impressive, it runs on a shoe string (about £200-£300 per month) and provides games and activities, classes (including religious instruction), clothes, dental checks and other basic medical care for the children who attend. It`s run by a mixture of foreign volunteers and Bolivians and on a quiet day the centre welcomes about 60, at the weekends and holidays it is overrun with about 150 children.

Quite how I managed to be persuaded to attend a "Bible Group" I am not quite sure. Julie was very convincing that her regulars would welcome the opportunity to learn more about the Jewish faith and it seemed something different to me I suppose. I was the only boy (what does this say?) out of the 9 attendees, we were a mixture of Americans, Australians, Germans, English and a Scot. All the girls worked for some kind of social or charitable project in Cochabamba and while I do not share their strong faith, the thing that struck me is that it is very positive if it spurs them on to this kind of work. It was an interesting evening, they were pleasant company and did not seem offended that I did not join in the group praying session. The one thing that puzzled me as a simple Jewish boy was how they distinguished so strongly between themselves as "Christians" and the majority of the local population who are "Catholics" as if it is a different religion.

3 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Many of what the world considers as "evangelical Christians" do not consider Catholics as Christians because the two faiths are so drastically different in some ways. For example Catholics regard as a higher authority the teachings of the Catholic church, the Pope, where the typical evangelical Christian places authority in scriptures. The list could go on and on. Obviously to the Jewish observer they would usually assume you believe in Jesus then you are Christian. But look closely right in Bolivia at the way the Catholic church portrays Jesus. In Catholocism Jesus is almost always portrayed as powerless either as an infant or being crucified. The image of Christ as risen savior, as conqueror of sin and death is seldom portrayed in popular Catholicism. Another great distinction is the way the Catholic church accepts the blending of animism (worship of Pachamama for example, liquid sacrifices of alchohol) with Catholocism. Is this to say that no individual Catholics are sincere in their love or devotion to God? No certainly not. Is this to say also that all who profess to be an evangelical or protestant are true Christians? Certainly not that either. However it is to point out that the Catholic church as an institution does not recognize the Bible as an ultimate authority on life or practice of the faith, it does not place a great deal of emphasis on Jesus' most unique traits as resurrected Lord and Saviour, nor does the catholic church as an institution seem to bothered by worship of God of the Bible (who by the way is the same God of Israel whom Jews worship) and simultaneous worship of mother earth or the virgin Mary. I hope this can shed some light on the subject. I can see how as a Jew the great division between Catholocism and evangelical Christians seems to be silly, but the differences are immense and the results are drastically different faiths and world views.

5:35 am

 
Blogger Julian said...

Many thanks for your succint, uncomplicated and enlightening explanation. I was aware of some of the points you raised and I definitely never thought of the division as 'silly' even if things sometimes come over as trivialised in the blog format.

6:38 pm

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

An interesting reply, but

'nor does the catholic church as an institution seem to bothered by worship of God of the Bible (who by the way is the same God of Israel whom Jews worship) and simultaneous worship of mother earth or the virgin Mary'

is ambiguous.

The main difference between the episcopalian churches (eg Catholicism, all the Orthodox ones, high church C of E) and the evangelical ones is the former's prerequisite of an intercedent between God and the congregation ie a priest. Evangelical religions are administered and a minister is (as anon said) an interpreter of the Bible... not God's ambassador on earth.

A Jewish friend of mine in the States made the interesting point that the Orthodox Hasidic Judaism is as similar to Liberal Judaism as Methodism is to Catholicism... I would rather people acknowledge these differences than pretend they don't exist. Methodists do not go to Confession or have a Day of Atonement.

I don't know about South America but in Cuba, Catholicism was adapted by African slaves to remember their Spiritual roots and is known as Santeria... (in extremis, though rare in Cuba because there is such a high level of literacy, a form of voodoo) where the European saints have their African counterparts and are worshipped thus. In Haiti where 85% of the population is illiterate, voodoo is still most prevalent. Santeria is interesting in that one offers a libation or drink usually a dish of water placed under the image of a saint (spirit) imitating the blood of Christ in Mass (the transformation of the body and blood into bread and wine being called 'transubstantiation'. It is said that if a Catholic does not believe in this act then one is not a true Catholic. My mother doesn't, she regards it as a symbolic event.

Anyway, it would be interesting to hear what an educated Bolivian has to say on the matter.

3:13 pm

 

Post a Comment

<< Home